Two nail polishes, not two prints
THE LONELY HEARTS CLUB and STAR SMUT are both nail polishes from Death Valley Nails, each topped with a removable handmade decorative bronze cap. If you are comparing them for a retail order, the real decision is which shade story fits your shelf and how you want to handle the cap — not which one is a 'better' print, because neither is a print.
Both share the same suggested application: a base coat, 2-3 coats of polish, and a top coat. Both are described as 10-free, vegan, cruelty-free, and nontoxic. The meaningful differences sit in color, finish, and the way the bronze cap affects your cost and display.
What each polish actually is
- THE LONELY HEARTS CLUB (Wholesale): Light pink. A soft, solid-looking pink is easy to merchandise as a gift or everyday shade, but the record does not specify finish beyond the color.

THE LONELY HEARTS CLUB (Wholesale) - STAR SMUT: Sheer multichrome teal/blue/pink with micro chartreuse gold glitter flecks. This is a shifting, glitter-flecked shade, so it reads very differently on the shelf and may appeal to customers looking for something more dimensional.

STAR SMUT
Shade and finish: solid pink vs shifting multichrome
THE LONELY HEARTS CLUB is listed simply as light pink, while STAR SMUT is a sheer multichrome that shifts between teal, blue, and pink with tiny chartreuse gold glitter. That difference matters for how customers shop: a light pink is often an easy add-on or gift, while a multichrome tends to attract customers already looking for a standout finish.
The catalog does not provide opacity, dry time, or wear-length details for either shade, so base your choice on the color story you can actually see and the application guidance both products share.
- THE LONELY HEARTS CLUB: Light pink. Best if your shelf needs a straightforward, soft shade that pairs easily with other polishes.
- STAR SMUT: Sheer multichrome teal/blue/pink with micro chartreuse gold glitter flecks. Best if you want a shade that changes with the light and stands out in a display.
The bronze cap decision applies to both
Both polishes arrive with a removable handmade decorative bronze cap on top of the standard black matte cap. The catalog notes you can choose to forego bronze caps on your order by clicking a link during purchase. That choice affects both the look of your display and how you handle inventory, but the supplied records do not include pricing or minimum-order differences for cap-free orders.
If you plan to sell the polish as a gift or display piece, the bronze cap is part of the appeal. If you prefer a simpler, lower-profile bottle for testers or backstock, the cap-free option is worth selecting at checkout. Just confirm the process with the store before you finalize a large order, since the exact steps beyond the catalog link are not spelled out here.
What the catalog does not settle before you stock
- Wear time and finish durability: Neither record lists wear length, drying time, or how the finish holds up, so you cannot compare them on performance from this information alone.
- Cap-free pricing or minimums: The records mention the option to forego bronze caps but do not state whether that changes cost, order minimums, or lead time.
- Display or tester guidance: No specific display, storage, or tester instructions are supplied for either polish beyond the application steps.
A practical way to choose between them
If your customers tend to reach for soft, giftable shades, THE LONELY HEARTS CLUB is the more direct fit. If your shop already carries unusual finishes or you want a shade that invites a second look, STAR SMUT gives you that shifting multichrome story. Many shops will find room for both: one as an easy everyday pink and one as the conversation piece.
Before ordering, decide whether you want bronze caps on both, on one, or on neither, and treat that as part of your display plan rather than an afterthought. The application guidance is the same for both, so your team can learn one routine: base coat, 2-3 coats, top coat.


